 | United States. Supreme Court - 1917 - 780 pages
...remedy, where the common law is competent to give it." The remedy which the Compensation Statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common...suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction. The Hine v. Trevor, 4 Wall. 555, 571, 572; The Belfast, 7 Wall. 624, 644; Steamboat Co. v. Chase, 16 Wall.... | |
 | 1919 - 924 pages
...Сотр. St II 991 (1) to 991 (25), 1233]) ; that the remedy given by our compensation statute was of a character wholly unknown to the common law, incapable...enforcement by the ordinary processes of any court, and therefore not saved to suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction under the foregoing statute.... | |
 | 1918 - 1332 pages
...common law is competent to give it.' The remedy which the [New York] compensation statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common...suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction. The Hiñe T. Trevor, 4 Wall. 571, 572, 18 L. Ed. 456: The Belfast, 7 Wall. 624. 644, 19 L. Ed. 266, 272;... | |
 | William Mark McKinney - 1921 - 1328 pages
...which the compensation statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common law, and incapable of enforcement by the ordinary processes...to suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction to the federal district court.6 Inasmuch as the supreme court decided that Congress, by enacting the... | |
 | 1917 - 1442 pages
...Constitution, and to that oxtent is invalid. * * * The remedy which the compensation statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common...suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction." The case, Clyde Steamship Co. v. Walker, involved identical principles, and was decided merely by reference... | |
 | 1917 - 1434 pages
...give is of a character wholly unknown to common law, incapable of enforcement by the ordinary process any court, and is not saved to suitors from the grant of es^' jurisdiction." The case, Clyde Steamship Co. v. Walker, involved identical : ciples, and was decided... | |
 | William Otis Badger - 1918 - 1272 pages
...remedy where the common law is competent to give it.' The remedy which the compensation statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common...suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction." This decision is conclusive of the case at bar. The Industrial Accident Commission was without jurisdiction... | |
 | New York (State). Industrial Commission - 1918 - 312 pages
...remedy where the common law is competent to give it." The remedy which the Compensation Statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common...suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction. In the Winfield case the Court refused to approve an award of compensation made by the Commission to... | |
 | New York (State). Legislature. Assembly - 1918 - 814 pages
...remedy where the common law is competent to give it." The remedy which the Compensation Statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common...suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction. In the Winfield case the Court refused to approve an award of compensation made by the Commission to... | |
 | Oberlin Historical and Improvement Organization, Ohio - 1918 - 896 pages
...remedy, where the common law is competent to give it.' The remedy which the compensation statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common...suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction." This ruling of the United States Supreme Court was based upon Article III, Section 2 of the Constitution... | |
| |
The remedy which the Compensation Statute attempts to give is of a character wholly unknown to the common law, incapable of enforcement by the ordinary processes of any court and is not saved to suitors from the grant of exclusive jurisdiction. 
