TO THE SAME. 'Aug. 7, 1755. DEAR SIR,-I told you that among the manuscripts are some things of Sir Thomas More. I beg you to pass an hour in looking on them, and procure a transcript of the ten or twenty first lines of each, to be compared with what I have; that I may know whether they are yet published. The manuscripts are these: 'Catalogue of Bodl. мs. pag. 122, F. 3, Sir Thomas More. 1. Fall of Angels. 2. Creation and fall of mankind. 3. Determination of the Trinity for the rescue of mankind. 4. Five lectures of our Saviour's passion. 5. Of the institution of the Sacrament, three lectures. 6. How to receive the blessed body of our Lord sacramentally. 7. Neomenia, the new moon. 8. De tristitia, tædio, pavore, et oratione Christi ante captionem ejus. 'Catalogue, page 154. Life of Sir Thomas More. Qu. Whether Roper's? Page 363. De resignatione Magni Sigilli in manus Regis per D. Thomam Morum. Page 364. Mori Defensio Moria. 'If you procure the young gentleman in the library to write out what you think fit to be written, I will send to Mr. Prince the bookseller to pay him what you shall think proper. 'Be pleased to make my compliments to Mr. Wise, and all my friends.-I am, sir, your affectionate, etc. 'SAM. JOHNSON.' has been often said, and I believe with justice, that there is for every thought a certain nice adaptation of words which none other could equal, and which, when a man has been so fortunate as to hit, he has attained, in that particular case, the perfection of language. The extensive reading which was absolutely necessary for the accumulation of authorities, and which alone may account for Johnson's retentive mind being enriched with a very large and various store of knowledge and imagery, must have occupied several years. The Preface furnishes an eminent instance of a double talent, of which Johnson was fully conscious. Sir Joshua Reynolds heard him say, 'There are two things which I am confident I can do very well: one is an introduction to any literary work, stating what it is to contain, and how it should be executed in the most perfect manner; the other is a conclusion, showing from various causes why the execution has not been equal to what the author promised to himself and to the public.' How should puny scribblers be abashed and disappointed, when they find him displaying a perfect theory of lexicographical excellence, yet at the same time candidly and modestly allowing that he had not satisfied his own expectations!' Here was a fair occasion for the exercise of Johnson's modesty, when he was called upon to compare his own arduous performance, not with those of other individuals (in which case his inflexible regard to truth would have been violated had he affected diffidence), but with speculative perfection; as he, who can outstrip all his competitors in the race, may yet be sensible of his deficiency when he runs against time. Well might he say, that 'the English Dictionary was written with little assistance of the learned;' for he told me, that the only aid which he received was a paper containing twenty etymolo The Dictionary, with a Grammar and History of the English Language, being now at length published, in two volumes folio, the world contemplated with wonder so stupendous a work achieved by one man, while other countries had thought such undertakings fit only for whole academies. Vast as his powers were, I cannot but think that his imagination deceived him, when he supposed that by constant applicationgies, sent to him by a person then unknown, he might have performed the task in three years. Let the Preface be attentively perused, in which is given, in a clear, strong, and glowing style, a comprehensive yet particular view of what he had done; and it will be evident that the time he employed upon it was comparatively short. I am unwilling to swell my book with long quotations from what is in everybody's hands, and I believe there are few prose compositions in the English language that are read with more delight, or are more impressed upon the memory, than that preliminary discourse. One of its excellences has always struck me with peculiar admiration; I mean the perspicuity with which he has expressed abstract scientific notions. As an instance of this, I shall quote the following sentence : 'When the radical idea branches out into parallel ramifications, how can a consecutive series be formed of senses in their own nature collateral?' We have here an example of what who, he was afterwards informed, was Dr. Pearce, Bishop of Rochester. The etymologies, though they exhibit learning and judgment, are not, I think, entitled to the first praise amongst the various parts of this immense work. The definitions have always appeared to me such astonishing proofs of acuteness of intellect and precision of language, as indicate a genius of the highest rank. This it is which marks the superior excellence of Johnson's Dictionary over others equally or even more voluminous, and must have made it a work of much greater mental labour than mere Lexicons, or WordBooks, as the Dutch call them. They who will make the experiment of trying how they can define a few words of whatever nature, will soon be satisfied of the unquestionable justice of this observation, which I can assure my readers is founded upon much study, and upon communication with more minds than my own. A few of his definitions must be admitted to be erroneous. Thus, Windward and Leeward, though directly of opposite meaning, are defined identically the same way; as to which inconsiderable specks it is enough to observe, that his Preface announces that he was aware there might be many such in so immense a work; nor was he at all disconcerted when an instance was pointed out to him. A lady once asked him how he came to define Pastern the knee of a horse; instead of making an elaborate defence, as she expected, he at once answered, 'Ignorance, madam,-pure ignorance.' His definition of Network has been often quoted with sportive malignity, as obscuring a thing in itself very plain. But to these frivolous censures no other answer is necessary than that with which we are furnished by his own Preface: 'To explain, requires the use of terms less abstruse than that which is to be explained, and such terms cannot always be found; for as nothing can be proved but by supposing something intuitively known, and evident without proof, so nothing can be defined but by the use of words too plain to admit of definition. Sometimes easier words are changed into harder; as burial into sepulture or interment; dry, into desiccative; dryness, into siccity or aridity; fit, into paroxysm: for the easiest word, whatever it be, can never be translated into one more easy.' His introducing his own opinions, and even prejudices, under general definitions of words, while at the same time the original meaning of the words is not explained, as his Tory, Whig, Pension, Oats, Excise, and a few more, cannot He owns in his Preface the deficiency of the technical part of his work; and he said he should be much obliged to me for definitions of musical terms for his next edition, which he did not live to superintend.-BURNEY. * He thus defines Excise: A hateful tax levied upon commodities, and adjudged not by the common judges of property, but wretches hired by those to whom Excise is paid.' The Commissioners of Excise being offended by this severe reflection, consulted Mr. Murray, then Attorney-General, to know whether redreas could be legally obtained. I wished to have proeured for my readers a copy of the opinion which he gave, and which may now be justly considered as history; but the mysterious secrecy of office, it seems, would not permit it. I am, however, informed by very good authority, that its import was, that the passage might be considered as actionable; but that it would be more prudent in the board not to proseeute Johnson never made the smallest alteration in this passage. We find he still retained his early prejedice against Excise; for in the Idler, No. 65, there is the following very extraordinary paragraph:-'The authenticity of Clarendon's History, though printed with the sanction of one of the first Universities of the world, had not an unexpected manuscript been happily discovered, would, with the help of factious credulity, have been brought into question by the two lowest of all human beings, a scribbler for a party, and a Commassioner of Excise.' The persons to whom he ades were Mr. John Oldmixon and George Ducket, E-BOSWELL. be fully defended, and must be placed to the account of capricious and humorous indulgence. Talking to me upon this subject when we were at Ashbourne in 1777, he mentioned a still stronger instance of the predominance of his private feelings in the composition of this work, than any now to be found in it. 'You know, sir, Lord Gower forsook the old Jacobite interest. When I came to the word renegado, after telling that it meant " one who deserts to the enemy, a revolter," I added, Sometimes we say a GOWER. Thus it went to the press; but the printer had more wit than I, and struck it out.' Let it, however, be remembered, that this indulgence does not display itself only in sarcasm towards others, but sometimes in playful allusion to the notions commonly entertained of his own laborious task. Thus: 'Grub Street, the name of a street in London, much inhabited by writers of small histories, dictionaries, and temporary poems; whence any mean production is called Grub Street.'-' Lexicographer, a writer of dictionaries, a harmless drudge.' At the time when he was concluding his very eloquent Preface, Johnson's mind appears to have been in such a state of depression, that we cannot contemplate without wonder the vigorous and splendid thoughts which so highly distinguish that performance. 'I,' says he, may surely be contented without the praise of perfection, which if I could obtain in this gloom of solitude, what would it avail me? I have protracted my work till most of those whom I wished to please have sunk into the grave; and success and miscarriage are empty sounds. I therefore dismiss it with frigid tranquillity, having little to fear or hope from censure or from praise.' That this indifference was rather a temporary than an habitual feeling, appears, I think, from his letters to Mr. Warton; and however he may have been affected for the moment, certain it is that the honours which his great work procured him, both at home and abroad, were very grateful to him. His friend the Earl of Cork and Orrery, being at Florence, presented it to the Academia della Crusca. That Academy sent Johnson their Vocabulario, and the French Academy sent him their Dictionnaire, which Mr. Langton had the pleasure to convey to him. It must undoubtedly seem strange that the conclusion of his Preface should be expressed in terms so desponding, when it is considered that the author was then only in his forty-sixth year. But we must ascribe its gloom to that miserable dejection of spirits to which he was constitutionally subject, and which was aggravated by the death of his wife two years before. I have heard it ingeniously observed by a lady of rank and elegance, that 'his melancholy was then at its meridian.' It pleased God to grant him almost thirty years of life after this time; and once, when he was in a placid frame of mind, he was obliged to own to me that he had enjoyed happier days, and had many more friends, since that gloomy hour than before. It is a sad saying, that 'most of those whom he wished to please had sunk into the grave;' and his case at forty-five was singularly unhappy, unless the circle of his friends was very narrow. I have often thought, that as longevity is generally desired, and I believe generally expected, it would be wise to be continually adding to the number of our friends, that the loss of some may be supplied by others. Friendship, the wine of life,' should, like a wellstocked cellar, be thus continually renewed; and it is consolatory to think, that although we can seldom add what will equal the generous first growths of our youth, yet friendship becomes insensibly old in much less time than is commonly imagined, and not many years are required to make it very mellow and pleasant. Warmth will, no doubt, make a considerable difference. Men of affectionate temper and bright fancy will coalesce a great deal sooner than those who are cold and dull. The proposition which I have now endeavoured to illustrate was, at a subsequent period of his life, the opinion of Johnson himself. He said to Sir Joshua Reynolds, 'If a man does not make new acquaintance as he advances through life, he will soon find himself left alone. A man, sir, should keep his friendship in constant repair.' The celebrated Mr. Wilkes, whose notions and habits of life were very opposite to his, but who was ever eminent for literature and vivacity, sallied forth with a little jeu d'esprit upon the following passage in his Grammar of the English Tongue, prefixed to the Dictionary:-H seldom, perhaps never, begins any but the first syllable.' In an essay printed in the Public Advertiser, this lively writer enumerated many instances in opposition to this remark: for example, 'The author of this observation must be a man of quick appre-hension, and of a most compre-hensive genius.' The position is undoubtedly expressed with too much latitude. This light sally, we may suppose, made no great impression on our lexicographer; for we find that he did not alter the passage till many years afterwards.1 He had the pleasure of being treated in a very different manner by his old pupil Mr. Garrick, in the following complimentary epigram : : 'ON JOHNSON'S DICTIONARY. 'Talk of war with a Briton, hell boldly advance That one English soldier will beat ten of France; 1.In the third edition, published in 1773, he left out the words perhaps never, and added the following paragraph: It sometimes begins middle or final syllables in words compounded, as block-head, or derived from the Latin, as compre-hended.'-BosWELL. Would we alter the boast from the sword to the pen, Can their strength be compared to Locke, Newton, and Boyle? Let them rally their heroes, send forth all their pow'rs, Their verse-men and prose-men, then match them with ours! First Shakspeare and Milton, like gods in the fight, Have put their whole drama and epic to flight; In satires, epistles, and odes would they cope, Their numbers retreat before Dryden and Pope; And Johnson, well-arm'd, like a hero of yore, Has beat forty French, and will beat forty more !' Johnson this year gave at once a proof of his benevolence, quickness of apprehension and admirable art of composition, in the assistance which he gave to Mr. Zachariah Williams, father of the blind lady whom he had humanely received under his roof. Mr. Williams had followed the profession of physic in Wales; but having a very strong propensity to the study of natural philosophy, had made many ingenious advances towards a discovery of the longitude, and repaired to London in hopes of obtaining the great parliamentary reward. He failed of success; but Johnson having made himself master of his principles and experiments, wrote for him a pamphlet, published in quarto, with the following title: 'An account of an Attempt to ascertain the Longitude at Sea, by an exact Theory of the Variation of the Magnetical Needle; with a Table of the Variations at the most remarkable Cities in Europe, from the year 1660 to 1860' [+]. To diffuse it more extensively, it was accompanied with an Italian translation on the opposite page, which it is supposed was the work of Signor Baretti,2 an Italian of considerable literature, who, having come to England a few years before, had been employed in the capacity both of a language master and an author, and formed an intimacy with Dr. John i The number of the French Academy employed in settling their language.-BoSWELL. 2 This ingenious foreigner, who was a native of Piedmont, came to England about the year 1753, and died in London, May 5, 1789. A very candid and judicions account of him and his works, beginning with the words 'So much asperity,' and written, it is believed, by a distinguished dignitary in the Church, may be found in the Gentleman's Magazine for that year, p. 469.-MALONE. 3 On Saturday the 12th, about twelve at night, died Mr. Zachariah Williams, in his eighty-third year, after an illness of eight months, in full possession of his mental faculties. He has been long known to philosophers and seamen for his skill in magnetism, and his proposal to ascertain the longitude by a peculiar In July this year he had formed some scheme of mental improvement, the particular purpose of which does not appear. But we find in his Prayers and Meditations, p. 25, a prayer entitled, 'On the Study of Philosophy as an instrument of living;' and after it follows a note, This study was not pursued.' On the 13th of the same month he wrote in his Journal the following scheme of life, for Sunday; having lived,' as he with tenderness of conscience expresses himself, 'not without an habitual reverence for the Sabbath, yet without that attention to its religious duties which Christianity requires :' work, the money for which he had contracted to write his Dictionary. We have seen that the reward of his labour was only fifteen hundred and seventy-five pounds; and when the expense of amanuenses and paper, and other articles, are deducted, his clear profit was very inconsiderable. I once said to him, I am sorry, sir, you did not get more for your Dictionary.' His answer was, I am sorry too. But it was very well. The booksellers are generous, liberal-minded men.' He, upon all occasions, did ample justice to their character in this respect. He considered them as the patrons of literature; and, indeed, although '1. To rise early; and in order to it, to go to they have eventually been considerable gainers sleep early on Saturday. by his Dictionary, it is to them that we owe 2. To use some extraordinary devotion in its having been undertaken and carried through the morning. at the risk of great expense, for they were not absolutely sure of being indemnified. 3. To examine the tenor of my life, and particularly the last week; and to mark my advances in religion, or recession from it. 4. To read the Scripture methodically, with from sickness [Pr. and Med.], and in February such helps as are at hand. '5. To go to church twice. that his eye was restored to its use [Pr. and Med. p. 27]. The pious gratitude with which he '6. To read books of divinity, either specula- acknowledges mercies upon every occasion is tive or practical. 7. To instruct my family. very edifying; as is the humble submission which he breathes, when it is the will of his 8. To wear off by meditation any worldly heavenly Father to try him with afflictions. soil contracted in the week.' CHAPTER XI. 1756-1758. Is 1756 Johnson found that the great fame of his Dictionary had not set him above the necessity of making provision for the day that was passing over him.'1 No royal or noble patron extended a munificent hand to give independence to the man who had conferred stability on the language of his country. We may feel indignant that there should have been such unworthy neglect; but we must, at the same time, congratulate ourselves when we consider, that to this very neglect, operating to rouse the natural indolence of his constitution, we owe many valuable productions, which otherwise perhaps might never have appeared. As such dispositions become the state of man here, and are the true effects of religious discipline, we cannot but venerate in Johnson one of the most exercised minds that our holy religion hath ever formed. If there be any thoughtless enough to suppose such exercise the weakness of a great understanding, let them look up to Johnson, and be convinced that what he so earnestly practised must have a rational founda tion. His works this year were, an abstract or epitome, in octavo, of his folio Dictionary, and a few essays in a monthly publication entitled The Universal Visitor. Christopher Smart, with whose unhappy vacillation of mind he sincerely sympathized, was one of the stated undertakers of this miscellany; and it was to assist him that Johnson sometimes employed his pen. All the essays marked with two asterisks have been ascribed to him; but I am confident, from internal evidence, that of these, He had spent, during the progress of the neither The Life of Chaucer,' Reflections on the State of Portugal,' nor an Essay on Architecture,' were written by him. I am equally He was a system of the variation of the compass. He was so far from being set above the necessity of making provision for the day that was passing over him, that he appears to have been in this year in great pecuniary distress, having been arrested for dest; on which occasion his friend Samuel Richarda became his surety. See a letter from Johnson to him on that subject, dated Feb. 19, 1756. Richardson's Correspondence, vol. v. p. 283.-MALONE. 6 In April in this year, Johnson wrote a letter to Dr. Joseph Warton, in consequence of having read a few pages of that gentleman's newly published Essay on the Genius and Writings of Pope. The only paragraph in it that respects Johnson's personal history is this: For my part, I have not lately done much. I have been ill in the winter, and my eye has been inflamed; but I please myself with the hopes of doing many things, with which I have long pleased and deceived myself!' Memoirs of Dr. J. Warton, etc., 4to, 1806. -MALONE procerity.' For this Anglo-Latian word procerity Johnson had, however, the authority of Addison. His reviews are of the following books: 'Birch's History of the Royal Society '[+]; Murphy's Gray's-Inn Journal '[+]; 'Warton's Essay on the Writings and Genius of Pope,' vol. i. [+]; 'Hampton's Translation of Polybius '[+]; 'Blackwell's Memoirs of the Court of Augustus '[+]; 'Russell's Natural History of Aleppo' [+]; 'Sir Isaac Newton's Arguments in confident, upon the same evidence, that he wrote Further Thoughts on Agriculture '[+]; being the sequel of a very inferior essay on the same subject, and which, though carried on as if by the same hand, is both in thinking and expression so far above it, and so strikingly peculiar, as to leave no doubt of its true parent; and that he also wrote A Dissertation on the State of Literature and Authors' [+], and 'A Dissertation on the Epitaphs written by Pope'[*]. The last of these, indeed, he after-Proof of a Deity '[+]; 'Borlase's History of the wards added to his Idler. Why the essays truly written by him are marked in the same manner with some which he did not write, I cannot explain; but with deference to those who have ascribed to him the three essays which I have rejected, they want all the cha-logue of the Scottish Bishops'[+]; 'Browne's racteristical marks of Johnsonian composition. Isles of Scilly '[+]; 'Holme's Experiments on History of Jamaica '[+]; 'Philosophical Transactions,' vol. xlix. [+]; Mrs. Lennox's Translation of Sully's Memoirs '[*]; 'Miscellanies, by Elizabeth Harrison'[+]; 'Evans's Map and Account of the Middle Colonies in America '[+]; Letter on the Case of Admiral Byng '[*]; 'Appeal to the People concerning Admiral Byng'[*] ; Hanway's Eight Days' Journey, and Essay on Tea '[*]; 'The Cadet, a Military Treatise '[+]; Some further Particulars in relation to the Case of Admiral Byng, by a Gentleman of Oxford' [*]; 'The Conduct of the Ministry relating to the Present War impartially examined '[+]; He engaged also to superintend and contribute largely to another monthly publication, entitled The Literary Magazine or Universal Review [*], the first number of which came out in May this year. What were his emoluments from this undertaking, and what other writers were employed in it, I have not discovered. He continued to write in it, with intermissions, till the fifteenth number; and I think that he never gave better proofs of the force, acuteness, and vivacity of his mind, than in this miscellany, whether we consider his original essays or his reviews of the works of others. The 'Pre-A Free Inquiry into the Nature and Origin of liminary Address '[+] to the public is a proof how this great man could embellish with the graces of superior composition even so trite a thing as the plan of a magazine. His original essays are: An Introduction to the Political State of Great Britain' [+]; 'Remarks on the Militia Bill' [+]; Observations on his Britannic Majesty's Treaties with the Empress of Russia and the Landgrave of Hesse Cassel'[+]; 'Observations on the Present State of Affairs '[t]; and 'Memoirs of Frederick III. King of Prussia '[t]. In all these he displays extensive political knowledge and sagacity, expressed with uncommon energy and perspicuity, without any of those words which he sometimes took a pleasure in adopting, in imitation of Sir Thomas Brown, of whose Christian Morals he this year gave an edition, with his 'Life' [*] prefixed to it, which is one of Johnson's best biographical performances. In one instance only in these essays has he indulged his Brownism. Dr. Robertson, the historian, mentioned it to me, as having at once convinced him that Johnson was the author of the Memoirs of the King of Prussia. Speaking of the pride which the old king, the father of his hero, took in being master of the tallest regiment in Europe, he says: To review this towering regiment was his daily pleasure; and to perpetuate it was so much his care, that when he met a tall woman, he immediately commanded one of his Titanian retinue to marry her, that they might propagate Evil'[*]. All these, from internal evidence, were written by Johnson; some of them I know he avowed, and have marked them with an asterisk accordingly. Mr. Thomas Davis, indeed, ascribed to him the Review of Mr. Burke's Inquiry into the Origin of our Ideas of the Sublime and Beautiful; and Sir John Hawkins, with equal discernment, has inserted it in his collection of Johnson's works; whereas it has no resemblance to Johnson's composition, and is well known to have been written by Mr. Murphy, who has acknowledged it to me and many others. It is worthy of remark, in justice to Johnson's political character, which has been misrepresented as abjectly submissive to power, that his Observations on the Present State of Affairs glow with as animated a spirit of constitutional liberty as can be found anywhere. Thus he begins: The time is now come, in which every Englishman expects to be informed of the national affairs, and in which he has a right to have that expectation gratified. For, whatever may be urged by Ministers, or those whom vanity or interest make the followers of Ministers, concerning the necessity of confidence in our governors, and the presumption of prying with profane eyes into the recesses of policy, it is evident that this reverence can be claimed only by counsels yet unexecuted, and projects suspended in deliberation. But when a design has ended in miscarriage or success, when every |