.

Boston Electric Light Co. v. Boston
Terminal Co., 184 Mass. 566, 570, 379
Boston v. Union Freight R.R. Co.,
181 Mass. 205,
Bowditch v. New England Life Ins.
Co., 141 Mass. 292,
172
Bowen v. Matheson, 14 Allen 499, 528
Boyden v. Massachusetts Masonic

Life Assn., 167 Mass. 242, .
Boylston v. Princeton, 13 Mass. 381,
Braily v. Southboro, 6 Cush. 141,
Brewer Brick Co. v. Brewer, 62 Me.
62, .

Brickett v. Haverhill Aqueduct Co., 142 Mass. 394, .

.

PAGE

144

Brodbine v. Revere, 182 Mass. 598,
600, 602, 603, 15, 89, 388, 425, 510.
Brooks v. Fitchburg & Leominster
Ry. Co., 200 Mass. 8, 17,

. 298 v. West Springfield, 193 Mass. 190, 432 Brown v. Lowell, 8 Met. 172, . 298, 594 v. Russell, 166 Mass. 14, 25, 26, 159, 307, 327 Cambridge v. Trelegan, 181 Mass. 565,

Capen v. Foster, 12 Pick. 485, 488, 500, 501, 510 Case of Supervisors of Elections, 114 Mass. 247, .

Caverly-Gould Co. v. Springfield, 83 Vt. 396, 403, 388 Chalfont v. State, 37 Ohio St. 60, . 312 Chamberlain v. Stearns, 111 Mass.

220

69

176

388

598

87

222

267,

13, 31 Charlestown v. Gardner et al, 98 Mass. 587,

Cheney v. Barker, 198 Mass. 356, 362, 376, 378 v. Charles

City National Bank

Baker Co., 180 Mass. 40, Cleveland, etc., Ry. Co. v. Illinois, 177 U. S. 514,

Codman v. Crocker, 203 Mass. 146, 152, 153, Coe v. Columbus, etc., R.R. Co., 10 Ohio 372, . 332

38

144

239

408

PAGE

53, 98, 102,

Cohn v. Parker, 41 La. Annual 894, 127 Cole v. Tucker, 164 Mass. 486, 500, 510 Commonwealth v. Alger, 7 Cush. 16, 277, 501, 502, 528 v. Bearse, 132 Mass. 542, 546, 277, 501, 502, 528 v. Berkshire Life Ins. Co., 98 Mass. 25, .

549,

286

v. Boston Advertising Co., 188 Mass. 348, 351,

v. Danziger, 176 Mass. 290,

291,

501

v. Davis, 162 Mass. 510, 511, . 408

v. Everson, 140 Mass. 292,

9 572

v. Gorham, 99 Mass. 420,
v. Hamilton

500, 501 510 186, 333

429,

101, 103

16

v. Vincent, 108 Mass. 441, v. Waterborough, 5 Mass. 257, 155 v. Wilkins, 121 Mass. 356, 39 Connecticut Insurance Co. v. Commonwealth, 133 Mass. 161, 166, 22, 285, 286 Conner v. Shepherd, 15 Mass. 164, 532

249

Coomes v. Burt, 22 Pick. 422,
Copeland v. Springfield, 166 Mass.
498,

Coster v. Tide Water Co., 3 C. E.
Green, 54, 518, .

Coughlan v. Cambridge, 166 Mass.
268,
45, 465
Covington & Lexington Turnpike
Co. v. Sandford, 164 U. S. 578,
597, 598,
Crocker v. Old Colony R.R. Co., 137
Mass. 417,

Crowell v. Cape Cod Ship Canal
Co., 168 Mass. 157,

Cunningham v. Mahan, 112 Mass.
58, 59,

Daly v. National Life Ins. Co., 64
Ind. 1,

163

503

Davies v. McKeeby, 5 Nev. 369,
Davis' Case, 122 Mass. 324, .
Day v. Hurlburt, 11 Met. 321,

440

540

v. Lawrence, 167 Mass. 371, . 385
Delaware, Lackawanna & Western
R.R. Co. v. Pennsylvania, 198
U. S. 341,

Detroit v. Detroit Citizens St. Ry.
Co., 184 U. S. 368, 398, 398, 402
Dobbins v. Commissioners of Erie

.

.

.

.

PAGE

540

East Boston Co. v. Commonwealth, 203 Mass. 68,

Ela v. Smith, 5 Gray, 121,

Emerson v. Trustees of Milton Acad

County, 16 Pet. 435, 299 Donnell v. Starlight, 103 Mass. 227, 10 Donworth v. Sawyer, 94 Me. 242, 535 Dow v. Beidelman, 125 U. S. 680, . 396 Dowling v. Insurance Co., 92 Wis. 73, 221 Drake v. Curtis, 1 Cush. 395, 16 535

v. Wells, 11 Allen, 141,

Earle v. Commonwealth, 180 Mass.

579,

298

541

.

398

105

11

468

246

506

. 274

489, 518

emy, 185 Mass. 414, 415,

Evangelical Baptist Society v. Boston, 192 Mass. 412,

387 Ex parte Quarg, 149 Cal. 79, 491, 492 Fargo v. Hart, 193 U. S. 490, 245, 246 Farwell v. Boston, 192 Mass. 15, 19, 555

248

416

Frothingham v. Shaw, 175 Mass. 59, 301 Gage v. Tirrell, 9 Allen, 299, 307, 41 Galveston, Harrisburg, etc., Railroad

v. Texas, 210 U. S. 217, 226, 245, 246 Gamble v. Queens County Water Co., 123 N. Y. 91,

Gardner v. The Collector, 6 Wall. 499, 511, .

396

Georgia Railroad & Banking Co. v. Smith, 128 U. S. 174, Georgia v. Tennessee Copper Co., 206 U. S. 230, 237, . 599, 603 Gibbons v. United States, 8 Wall. 274,

Grace v. Board of Health of Newton, 135 Mass. 490, . 540 Graham v. Roberts, 200 Mass. 152, 425 Grand Lodge v. New Orleans, 166 . 387 Green v. Shumway, 39 N. Y. 418, . 503 Griffith v. Berkshire Power Co., 158 Fed. 219,

U. S. 143, 149, .

598 Haberlil v. Boston, 190 Mass. 358, 384 Hamilton Mfg. Co. v. Lowell, 185 Mass. 114,

25

535

332

554

Hamlin v. New Bedford, 143 Mass. 192, Hannum v. Tourtellott, 10 Allen 494,

77,

Hanscom v. Lowell, 165 Mass. 419,

151

36

545

468

381

. 387

Hardy v. Waltham, 7 Pick. 108, Harpending v. Haight, 39 Cal. 189, 556, 558 Hartwell v. Littleton, 13 Pick. 229, 39 Harvard College v. Cambridge, 175 Mass. 145,

v. Kettell, 16 Mass. 204,

248 . 387

.

Home Insurance Co. v. New York, 134 U. S. 594, Hopkins v. United States, 171 U. S. 578,

poration, 184 Mass. 177, 220 Higginson v. Nahant, 11 Allen 530, 381 Holman v. Townsend, 13 Met. 297, Holt v. City Council of Somerville, 127 Mass. 408,

176

.

.

PAGE

266

535

.

399

Kilty v. Railroad Commissioners,
184 Mass. 310, .
King v. Concordia Fire Ins. Co., 140
Mich. 258, 268,

540

234

176

172

€ 458

540

467,

381, 382 Hudson Real Estate Co. v. Tower, 156 Mass. 82,

Hughes v. Berkshire Power Co., 158 Fed. 219, . 598 Hutchins v. State Bank, 12 Met. 421, Interstate Ry. Co. v. Massachusetts,

207 U. S. 79, 85, 86, 87, . 389, 390, 396, 398, 399, 402 Jaquith v. Wellesley, 171 Mass. 138, 143, 501 Jenkins v. Andover, 103 Mass. 94, 76, 156, 157 Kansas v. Colorado, 185 U. S. 125, 600 Kentucky v. Dennison, 24 How. 66, 433, 438

408

249

121

104

513

221

522 Loewe v. Lawlor, 208 U. S. 274, 234 Louisville & Nashville R.R. Co. v.

Kentucky, 161 U. S. 677, . 238, 239 v. Kentucky, 183 U. S. 503, 519,. 239 Lowell v. Boston, 111 Mass. 454, 154, 161, 162, 305, 486, 487, 505, 522, 540, 542

v. Oliver, 8 Allen, 247, 253, 161, 305, 380, 486 Lumbard v. Stearns, 4 Cush. 60, 109 Lyons v. Woods, 153 U. S. 649, 663, 554 Mahoney v. Boston, 171 Mass. 427, 164 v. Fitzpatrick, 133 Mass. 151, 523 Maine v. Grand Trunk Ry. Co., 142 U. S. 217,

246 Major v. Holmes, 124 Mass. 108, 120, 261 Malcolm v. Boston, 173 Mass. 312, 168 Manufacturers Ins. Co. v. Loud, 99 Mass. 146,

Manville Co. v. Worcester, 138 Mass. 89,. 600

Martell v. White, 185 Mass. 255, 260, 528, 529 Massachusetts Agricultural College v. Marden, 156 Mass. 150, 156, . 311

164

Massachusetts Society for Prevention of Cruelty, etc. v. Boston, 142, Mass. 24,

.

Massachusetts Western Union Tele

graph Co., 141 U. S. 40, 245 McAuley v. Boston, 113 Mass. 503, 176 McDonald v. Union Freight Railroad Co., 190 Mass. 123, 144 McGowan v. Boston, 170 Mass, 384, 176 McNichols v. Pease, 207 U. S. 100, 435 Mead v. Acton, 139 Mass. 341, 344,

421 301

155, 161, 305, 486, 487 Meands v. Park, 95 Me. 527, Melcher v. Boston, 9 Met. 73, Merrick v. Amherst, 12 Allen, 500, 76, 77, 157, 382, 388 Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Commonwealth, 198 Mass. 466, 285 Miller v. Fitchburg, 180 Mass. 32, 37, .

.

.

Minneapolis v. Minneapolis St. Ry.
Co., 215 U. S. 417, 434,
398, 402
Minneapolis & St. Louis R.R. Co. v.

396

Minnesota, 186 U. S. 257, Minot v. Winthrop, 162 Mass. 113, 124, 285, 386 Missouri v. Illinois, 200 U. S. 496, 521, 599, 600, 602 Missouri Pacific Railway v. Larrabee Mills, 211 U. S. 612, 621, 239 Monies v. Lynn, 121 Mass. 442, 175 Monongahela Navigation Co. v.

United States, 148 U. S. 312, 545 Montague & Co. v. Lowry, 193 U. S. 38, 234 Morris v. Callanan, 105 Mass. 129, 533 Moses v. Lawrence County Bank,

149 U. S. 298, 302,

PAGE

13

543

343

Newburyport Water Co. v. Newburyport, 85 Fed. Rep. 723, 545 New England Telephone & Tele

graph Co. v. Boston Terminal Co., 182 Mass. 397, 399, New England Theosophical Society v. Boston, 172 Mass. 60, New Hampshire v. Louisiana, 108 U. S. 76, 598, 599 New Orleans v. Arthurs, 36 La. Ann. 98,

13, 31

New York Life Ins. Co. v. Hardison, 199 Mass. 190, . 220, 221 11

Nimbus (The), 137 Mass. 360, Northampton v. County Commissioners, 145 Mass. 108, 295, 387 Northern Securities Co. v. United States, 193 U. S. 197, Northside Railway Co. v. Worthington, 88 Tex. 562,

332 . 266

Noyes v. Hale, 137 Mass. 266, O'Hanlan v. Denvir, 81 Cal. 60, 535 O'Keefe v. Somerville, 190 Mass. 110, . 528 Old Dominion Copper Co. V. Bigelow, 188 Mass. 315, 321, 329, 313 203 Mass. 159, 177, 178, . 313 Oliver v. Gale, 182 Mass. 39, 197

v. Washington Mills, 11 Allen, 268, 275, 286, 295 O'Neil v. Insurance Co., 166 Pa. St. 77, Opinion of the Justices, 13 Allen, 594,

5 Met. 591, 592, 99 Mass. 636, 107 Mass. 604, 115 Mass. 602, 117 Mass. 603, 135 Mass. 594,

136 Mass. 578,

150 Mass. 586, 591, 592, 155 Mass. 598, 601, 160 Mass. 586, 590, 165 Mass. 599,

166 Mass. 589, 175 Mass. 602,

.

PAGE

376

127

234

. 228

500

. 555

. 446

446

549

555

. 446 109, 446

109, 486, 540

88,388, 425

446

159, 307
. 152

221

Opinion of the Justices, 182 Mass.

605, 607, .

186 Mass. 603, 605,

110,540, 546 161, 162, 486, 505 190 Mass. 611, 613, 161, 486, 505 195 Mass. 607, 608-9, 614, 287, 294, 300, 302, 386, 411 380 442 . 569 558 545

204 Mass. 607, 611,
208 Mass. 610,

209 Mass. 607,

45 N. H. 607, 610,
66 N. H. 629,

Owensboro National Bank v. Owens-
boro, 173 U. S. 664, 669, 410, 411
Paine v. Woods, 108 Mass. 160, 274
Parker v. Barnard, 135 Mass. 116, 101
v. Kane, 4 Allen, 346,
v. Nickerson, 112 Mass.

261

195,

196,

v. Nickerson, 137 Mass. 487, 497,

Pearsall v. Great Northern Ry. Co., 161 U. S. 647,

239 People v. Hawkins, 157 N. Y. Rep. 1, 496 v. Horn Silver Mining Co., 105 N. Y. 76,

v. Steele, 231 Ill. 340,
Perry v. Bangs, 161 Mass. 35, 36,
Peterson v. Chicago, Rock Island &
Pacific Ry. Co., 205 U. S. 364,
391,

Phillips Academy v. Andover, 175
Mass. 118,

Phillips v. Boston, 150 Mass. 491, Phoenix Ins. Co. v. Perkins, 19 So. Dak. 59,

PAGE

256 . 491 322

313

313

Pierce v. Creecy, 210 U. S. 387, Pittsburg, etc., Ry. Co. v. Backus, 154 U. S. 421, 428, 247 Plant v. Woods, 176 Mass. 492, 501, 528

Pollock v. Farmers Loan & Trust

418

387

167

221 437

Co., 157 U. S. 429,
158 U. S. 601,

Portland Bank v. Apthorp, 12 Mass.

252, 285, 286 Proprietors of Mills v. Commonwealth, 164 Mass. 227,

300, 301 300, 301

17

Provident Savings, etc., Society v.
Cutting, 181 Mass. 261,

Pullman Car Co. v. Missouri Pacific
Co., 115 U. S. 587,
418
Purinton v. Jamrock, 195 Mass. 187, 124
Quatsoe v. Eggleston, 42 Ore. 315, 585
Quinn v. Fire Association, 180 Mass.
560,
Railroad Co. v. Maryland, 21 Wall.
456,
239
Raymond v. Lowell, 6 Cush. 524, 176
Rice v. Bradford, 180 Mass. 545, . 387
Richards v. Barlow, 140 Mass. 218, 523
Richmond Iron Works v. Wadhams,

142 Mass. 569, .

532 503

Rison v. Farr, 24 Ark. 161,

Roberts v. Reilly, 116 U. S. 80, 97, 437 Robinson's Case, 131 Mass. 376, 445 Rockport v. Webster, 174 Mass. 385, 450 Round v. Police Commissioner, 197 Mass. 218,

Sawyer v. State Board of Health,
125 Mass. 182, 192, .

Sears v. Crocker, 184 Mass. 586, 588,
376, 377
Shattuck v. Gragg, 23 Pick. 88, 534
Shawnee Compress Co. v. Anderson,

540

209 U. S. 423, 234, 237 Sherman v. Tobey, 3 Allen, 7, Shiffer v. Broadhead, 126 Penn. 260,

535

Silver v. Ladd, 7 Wall. 219,
Slater v. Jepherson, 6 Cush. 129,
Smith v. Dedham, 8 Cush. 522,

95 533 . 176

v. Dedham, 144 Mass. 177, . 328 Smyth v. Ames, 169 U. S. 466,

. 396 v. Ames, 171 U. S. 361, 365, . 397 v. Phillips Academy, 154 Mass. 551, 590 Soon Hing v. Crowley, 113 U. S. 703, 277 Southboro v. Marlboro, 24 Pick. 166, 115 Sprague v. Dorr, 185 Mass. 10, 304 v. Minon, 195 Mass. 581,

304, 450

PAGE

220

220

421

87