Page images
PDF
EPUB

by the Legislature with chapter 117 of the Acts of 1886 in mind. It must therefore have been intended by the Legislature to change the law so far as the city of Marlborough was concerned.

That a subsequent legislative act repeals all prior acts repugnant to it, is a principle which results from the unlimited nature of legislative power. The last expression of the legislative will must be carried into effect, as the law of the land. Brown v. Lowell, 8

Metc. 172.

It would therefore seem that the legislative intent was to repeal the general law as to the city of Marlborough. It has been said that it would require very strong terms in a general act to show that it was intended to supersede a special act in order to hold it to be such a repeal.

Here the two statutes are irreconcilable; they cannot be read together; they cover the same subject-matter; and it therefore appears to be the legislative will to repeal the prior general law so far as Marlborough is concerned, it having been done with full knowledge on the part of the Legislature of the provisions of the statute of 1886.

This being the legislative will, I feel it my duty to rule, what I believe to be the law, that the provision in the charter of the city of Marlborough must govern, and that if it is desired to change to conform to the general law, legislation should be asked for.

Informations in the nature of quo warranto, under the rule established by my predecessors, are signed by the Attorney-General only when the construction of a law affecting the Commonwealth generally is involved, or when the Commonwealth, as such, is for any reason interested in the determination of the question; but when the question is purely local, and one in which the Commonwealth is in no way interested, the reason for signing does not exist. In this case the question is a local one, involving the construction of the city charter of Marlborough alone; and I am unable to find such a case, presenting questions as to the construction of any law affecting the Commonwealth generally, as requires the Attorney-General to grant the use of his name to an information in the nature of quo warranto. For both of the reasons above named the application is therefore refused.

DANA MALONE, Attorney-General.

William M. Brigham, for the petitioner.

James W. McDonald, city solicitor, for the respondent.

INDEX TO OPINIONS.

Andover, theological institution, mandamus,

Appropriation from public funds to pay damages of act of insane person released on parole, constitutional law,

Appropriation for religious society, school or institution, constitutional law,

Appropriation of money not directly raised by taxation, public purpose, constitutional law,

Bond, register of deeds, statutory requirements,

Bookkeeper, civil service,

Certification of pay rolls, police force of city of Boston, Civil Service Commission,

Child labor, employment in factory or workshop, certificate of school au-
thorities,

City of Chelsea, appropriation in aid of, constitutional law,
City or town, aid rendered State pauper, notice, reimbursement,
Civil service, city bookkeeper, exemption,

Exemption, clerk of chief of police,

Civil Service Commission, police force of city of Boston, certification of

pay rolls,

Civil service rules, effect upon authority of Metropolitan Park Commission, punishment of police,

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small]

Commonwealth, liability of, damage by liquid asphalt on State highway, defect,

[blocks in formation]

Constitutional law, appropriation to pay damages for act of insane person released on parole, public purpose,

Appropriation from public funds for benefit of religious society, school or institution,

Appropriation of money not directly raised by taxation,.

Corporation organized under laws of District of Columbia, foreign corpo

ration,

Corporation, foreign, usual place of business,

Damage by liquid asphalt, State highway, liability of Commonwealth,
Debenture bonds, New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad Company,
investment for savings banks,

Director of insurance company, loans by,
District Police, inspection of buildings, jurisdiction,
Employment of children, factory, workshop or mercantile establishment, .
Factory, workshop or mercantile establishment, employment of child
under fourteen years, certificate of ability to read and write,

[blocks in formation]

Fisheries and game, pursuit of wild fowl,
Foreign corporation, corporation chartered under the laws of the District

[ocr errors][merged small][merged small]

of Columbia,

Usual place of business,

Funds, investment of, by insurance corporation,

[ocr errors]

History of military organizations of volunteers, approval, purchase of

copies,

8

Insane person, liability of Commonwealth for act of, released on parole, 10

[ocr errors]

Inspection of buildings, sanitation, District Police,

Insurance, investment of funds in secured loans and mortgages,
Loans by officers or directors of insurance company, investment of
funds,

Label, patent medicines, fractional parts,

Launch or power boat, pursuit of wild fowl,

Local question, quo warranto, city of Marlborough, superintendent of
streets,

Marlborough, city of, superintendent of streets, quo warranto,
Master in chancery, removal from county, vacancy,

Metropolitan Park Commission, authority to establish rules for govern

ment of its police force, civil service rules,

Military organization, history of, purchase of copies by Commonwealth, New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad Company, debenture bonds, savings bank investments,

[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]

Notice, aid rendered State pauper, by city or town, reimbursement,
Opinions upon applications, public charitable trust, Andover,
Original packages, fractional parts to be labelled, patent medicine,
Pauper, State, aid by city or town, notice, reimbursement,

Police force of city of Boston, certification of pay rolls, Civil Service Com-
mission,

[blocks in formation]

Police force of Metropolitan Park Commission, authority of commission to
punish for breach of regulations, effect of civil service rules,
Proprietary and patent medicines, label of fractional parts, prosecution,
Quo warranto, city of Marlborough, superintendent of streets,
Register of deeds, bond,

38

[ocr errors]

Retirement, of veteran in service of Commonwealth, compensation, Sanitation and ventilation, jurisdiction of District Police in inspection of buildings,

50

Savings banks, legal investment, New York, New Haven & Hartford
Railroad Company debenture bonds,

State Board of Health, label of proprietary medicines, prosecution,
State highway, defect or want of repair, liability of Commonwealth, dam-
age by liquid asphalt,

[blocks in formation]

Street railway corporation, taxation when in hands of receiver,
Taxation of street railway company in hands of receiver,
Usual place of business, foreign corporation,

45

2224

Veteran, retirement from service of Commonwealth, compensation,

1

LIST OF CASES

IN WHICH THE

ATTORNEY-GENERAL

HAS APPEARED

DURING THE YEAR 1908.

« PreviousContinue »