 | 1838 - 486 pages
...question of quantity, it must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of...to refer to any particular cases as to quantity." Now, there can hardly be anything less calculated to lay down a rule which would look at quantity only.... | |
 | Great Britain. Court of Chancery, James William Mylne, Richard Davis Craig - 1839 - 880 pages
...question of quantity, it must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of...to quantity. In my view of the law, Lord Eldon, in IViltins v. Aikin (/}, put the question on a most proper footing. He says " The question upon the whole... | |
 | United States. Circuit Court (1st Circuit), William Wetmore Story - 1842 - 668 pages
...question of quantity, it must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of...book in quantity. It is not only quantity, but value, which is looked to. It is useless to look to any particular cases about quantity."3 The same subject... | |
 | George Ticknor Curtis - 1847 - 490 pages
...question of quantity, it must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of...book in quantity. It is not only quantity, but value, which is looked to. It is useless to look to any particular cases about quantity.' The same subject... | |
 | George Ticknor Curtis - 1847 - 542 pages
...must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, though it might be a small proportion of the book in quantity. It is not only quantity, but value that is always looked to."1 This doctrine is not to be considered as affected by those decisions, in which courts of equity... | |
 | Robert Henley Eden Baron Henley - 1852 - 770 pages
...question of quantity, it must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of...book in quantity. It is not only quantity, but value, which is looked to. It is useless to look to any particular cases about quantity.' The same subject... | |
 | Great Britain. Court of Chancery - 1853 - 598 pages
...question of quantity, it must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part *of [*37] another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of...not only quantity, but value that is always looked to."(a) Besides, if the plaintiff had acquiesced in the defendants' taking a portion of his poems,... | |
 | 1862 - 590 pages
...quantity, it must bo very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, thongh it might be but a small proportion of the book in...quantity. In my view of the law, Lord Eldon, in Wilkins v. Áikin, puts the question on a most proper footing. He says: 'The question upon the whole is, whether... | |
 | Ireland. High Court of Chancery - 1864 - 668 pages
...question of quantity "it must be very vague: one writer might take all the vital part of "another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of...to refer to any particular cases as to quantity." He then refers to and approves of the opinion expressed by Lord Eldon in Wilhins v. Aihin (b), where... | |
 | Walter Arthur Copinger - 1870 - 448 pages
...question of quantity, it must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of...book in quantity. It is not only quantity, but value, which is looked at. It is useless to look to any particular case about quantity." The general principle... | |
| |
When it comes to a question of quantity, it must be very vague. One writer might take all the vital part of another's book, though it might be but a small proportion of the book in quantity. It is not only quantity but value that is always looked to.... 
