 The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question of power is not to be confused with the scope of legislative considerations in dealing with the matter of policy. Whether the enactment is wise or unwise, whether it is based on sound economic theory,...  Report - Page 220by Massachusetts. Dept. of Labor and Industries. Division of Statistics - 1913Full view - About this book
 | Illinois. Supreme Court - 1922 - 700 pages
...based upon it." So in Chicago, Burlington and Quincy Railway Co. v. McGuire, 219 US 549, it is said: "The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question...whether, in short, the legislative discretion within its prescribed limits should be exercised in a particular manner, are matters for the judgment of the... | |
 | New York (State). Attorney General's Office - 1922 - 524 pages
...question of policy for the Legislature. " The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question of poiver is not to be confused with the scope of legislative...considerations in dealing with the matter of policy." (People ex rel. Durham v. La Fetra, supra.) Nor should you overlook the fact that this opinion, given... | |
 | 1911 - 868 pages
...governmental authority, the exercise of the legislative discretion is not subject to judicial review. The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question...whether, in short, the legislative discretion within its prescribed limits should be exercised in a particular manner, are matters for the judgment of the... | |
 | Philip Joseph Doherty - 1911 - 388 pages
...governmental authority, the exercise of the legislative discretion is not subject to judicial review. The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question...whether, in short, the legislative discretion within its prescribed limits should be exercised in a particular manner, are matters for the judgment of the... | |
 | 1911 - 1202 pages
...governmental authority, the exercise of the legislative discretion is not subject to judicial review. The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question...wise or unwise, whether it is based on sound economic theorv, whether it is the best means to achieve the desired result, whether, in short, the legislative... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1911 - 760 pages
...governmental authority, the exercise of the legislative discretion is not subject to judicial review. The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question of power is not to be confused with the scope of Icgisltttive considerations in dealing with the matter of policy. Whether the enactment is wise or... | |
 | 1912 - 1526 pages
...constitutional. (Thayer, Legal Essays, P. 21.) Mr. Justice Hughes says, in the case last above cited : Whether the enactment Is wise or unwise, whether it Is based on sonnd economic theory, whether it is the best means to achieve the desired result, whether, in short,... | |
 | Massachusetts. Department of Labor and Industries. Division of Statistics - 1913 - 556 pages
...purview of a decision of the courts. That principle was thus stated in Chicago, Burlington £ Quincy EE Co. v. McGuire, 219 US 549, 569 : The scope of judicial...whether, in short, the legislative discretion within its prescribed limits should be exercised in a particular manner, are matters for the judgment of the... | |
 | Railroad Commission of the State of California - 1914 - 1048 pages
...quotes from Chicago, Burlington & Qidncy Railroad Company vs. McGuire, 219 US 549, 569, as follows: "The scope of judicial inquiry in deciding the question...whether, in short, the legislative discretion within its prescribed limits should be exercised in a particular manner, are matters for the judgment of the... | |
| |
