 | United States. Supreme Court, John Chandler Bancroft Davis, Henry Putzel, Henry C. Lind, Frank D. Wagner - 1887 - 714 pages
...some right, title, privilege, or immunity, on which the recovery depended, would be defeated by one construction of the Constitution or some law or treaty of the United States, or sustained by an opposite construction. Starin v. New York, 115 US 248, 257. Even if the complaint,... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1887 - 716 pages
...some right, title, privilege, or immunity, on which the recovery depended, would be defeated by one construction of the Constitution or some law or treaty of the United States, or sustained by an opposite construction. Starin v. New York, 115 US 248, 257. Even if the complaint,... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1887 - 712 pages
...some right, title, privilege, or immunity, on which the recovery depended, would be defeated by one construction of the Constitution or some law or treaty of the United States, or sustained by an opposite construction. Starin v. New York, 115 US 248, 257. Even if the complaint,... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1887 - 888 pages
...substantially involves a dispute or controversy ' as to a right which depends upon the construction or effect of the Constitution or some law or treaty of the United States." It is not enough for the party who seeks a removal of his cause to say that the suit is one arising... | |
 | 1914 - 1282 pages
...the law of the United States the United States Supreme Court has said : "But a suit does not so arise unless it really and substantially involves a dispute...the effect or construction of the Constitution, or validity or construction of the laws or treaties of the United States, upon the determination of which... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1889 - 860 pages
...States," the circuit court had no jurisdiction; and if it did not really and substantially involve a dispute or controversy as to the effect or construction of the constitution or some law, upon the determination of which the recovery depended, then it was not a suit so arising. Starin v.... | |
 | 1903 - 880 pages
...substantially involve a dispute or controversy as to a right which depends on the construction or application of the constitution or some law or treaty of the United States (Water Co. v. Keyes, 96 US 199, 24 L. Ed. 656; Blackburn v. Gold Min. Co., 175 US 571, 20 Sup. Ct.... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1894 - 756 pages
...We are of opinion that the case made upon bill and answer did not really and substantially involve a dispute or controversy as to the effect or construction of the Constitution, upon the determination of which the result of the suit depended. Reference is made in the argument... | |
 | 1925 - 1344 pages
...Sup. Ct. 867, 8G9 (44 L. Ed. 1052), that— "When a suit does not really and substantially involve a dispute or controversy as to the effect or construction of the Constitution or laws of the United States, upon the determination of which the result depends, it is not a suit arising... | |
| |
States, and that must be tested by the settled rule that a suit does not so arise unless it really and substantially involves a dispute or controversy as to the effect or construction of the Constitution or some law or treaty of the United States... 
